Welcome to Portland Pie Company
Portland Pie Company, located at 173 Main St, Waterville, ME, is a beloved destination for pizza enthusiasts. Renowned for its creative combination of toppings, such as the standout "County" pie featuring mashed potatoes, bacon, and caramelized onions, this pizzeria delivers on flavor and generous portions. While some guests have noted occasional service hiccups, the dedication to quality food shines through, as evidenced by rave reviews on the pizza's crust and overall taste. With a vibrant atmosphere and prompt service for large orders, Portland Pie Company is a must-visit for those craving a unique and satisfying meal.
Portland Pie Company: Reviews & Ratings
Brought my wife there for lunch I was extremely surprised.Were picky eaters...We we're very impressed Nothing to complain about with our meals everything was cooked perfectly the portions were plentiful.How ever The waitress was rude..And when we signalled her over she rolled her eyes and continued talking to the other waitress.had 2 ask her for many things she also had no idea about the menu.When asked she looked at us blankly the restaurant was clean thank you Portland pie company we will be back soon. For the food but not for the hospitality
Enjoyed "The County" "pizza?": mashed potatoes, bacon, carmelized onion and cheese? Yes please! Washed it down with a healthy Ginger beer. Son had the calzone, both were too much food but not too much that we couldn't lug it to the truck all boxed up for later. See you again!
I placed a large delivery order for an event. Their team was responsive, polite and very accommodating of last-minute requests. Everyone enjoyed the food, too!
The was a bit of a wait to sit but this was expected given the lunch rush. After fifteen minutes we were seated. Our server was Kyle and he made sure our experience was the best it could be. I ordered a pizza with Alfredo sauce and tomato and bacon. The pizza was excellent, especially the crust. Nice atmosphere, if a little loud (everywhere is loud for me). Well definitely return!
Excellent Pizza! Will definitely be going back and trying their other locations. My only issue is we ordered to go and the young lady said 15-20 min. that turned into 40-45m, it was in the afternoon and there were less than 6 people dining so it wasn't busy, but like I said at the beginning, the Pizza is SO over the top of other places that I will wait for it every time!.
Awesome food, awesome atmosphere, and love everything I've tired here! Visited here a few times, and wether you eat in or eat out, always awesome! Street parking, and usually pretty busy so as long as you don't mind being a little patient, it's always well worth the wait!
Absolutely delicious food. I got the macaroni and cheese dish and it was absolutely amazing. The focaccia is beautifully done! The salad was overflowing with fresh ingredients ! The apple cider vinegar dressing was so delicious. We will be back to try more!
Pizza and everything else is amazing - especially the spinach artichoke dip!!
Location
-
173 Main St, Waterville, ME 04901, United States Hotline: +1 207-401-6200
Welcome to Portland Pie Company, an esteemed pizza haven located at 173 Main St, Waterville, ME. With a passion for crafting extraordinary pies and a menu that tantalizes the taste buds, this brand has carved out a niche for itself in the vibrant culinary scene of Maine.
Patrons often rave about the unique flavor combinations that grace the menu, like the famous "County" pizza, featuring a delightful blend of mashed potatoes, bacon, caramelized onions, and melted cheese—an irresistible choice for any adventurous eater. The crust, hailed as a standout feature, boasts a perfect balance of crunch and chewiness, setting the stage for a remarkable pizza experience.
While the food shines brightly, some guests have noted areas for improvement in service, such as a few instances of inattentive waitstaff. However, many reviews reflect an overall positive atmosphere, often characterized by bustle and a lively dining vibe—perfect for family lunches or casual gatherings with friends. Customers appreciate that even during peak hours, meals are promptly served, and leftovers make for great midnight snacks!
The accommodating team at Portland Pie Company has also garnered praise for their responsiveness, making it a reliable choice for larger events or quick delivery orders. Many diners leave with a promise to return, drawn back not just by the delicious offerings but by the compelling community vibe that permeates the restaurant.
So, whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice, adventurous toppings, or a hearty calzone, Portland Pie Company stands ready to satisfy. Though some may have gripes with service, the overwhelming love for their pizza ensures this establishment is a must-visit. Bring a friend, share a pie, and savor the flavors that make Portland Pie Company a beloved local gem.